Maytag
-
Price Snapshot: Mid-range to mid-premium depending on series and features.
-
Product Focus: Straightforward Furnace / AC / Heat Pump options with a reputation for strong headline warranties.
-
Best For: Buyers who want a polished look and peace-of-mind coverage without going full luxury.
-
What Stands Out: Upscale fit-and-finish on upper lines and clear value messaging for whole-home replacements.
-
Before You Buy: Verify warranty registration steps and whether labor protection is available in your area.
-
Warranty/Dealer: Warranty terms are a key brand draw; double-check parts, compressor/heat-exchanger, transfer options and local service access.
Coleman
-
Price Snapshot: Mid-range with practical trims; not positioned as ultra-premium.
-
Product Focus: Complete Furnace / Central AC / Heat Pump lineup tuned for residential needs.
-
Best For: Homeowners who want solid, quiet comfort without luxury pricing, especially in suburban installs near bedrooms/patios.
-
What Stands Out: Quiet outdoor units on higher tiers and straightforward control options that are easy to live with.
-
Before You Buy: Dealer strength varies by area; pick an authorized installer with strong references; confirm thermostat compatibility.
-
Warranty/Dealer: Competitive parts coverage under a major family brand; verify labor add-ons and registration/transfer terms.
Similar Comparison
View All
Maytag HVAC
Maytag has a long history in American households, originally known for appliances and now also a recognized name in heating and cooling. The residential HVAC lineup is designed to balance dependable comfort, efficiency, and warranty protection, with products often favored by families who want equipment that will last.
For this review, I’ll focus on three representative models: the PGC2TE-VS Gas Furnace, the PSA4BF Air Conditioner, and the PSH4BE Heat Pump. Together, they show how the company approaches both traditional gas heating and modern electric cooling and heating. These systems are built with reliability and everyday performance in mind, while also offering warranties that give homeowners peace of mind.
Coleman HVAC
Coleman may be best known for its camping gear, but in HVAC, it’s part of the Johnson Controls family, sharing engineering DNA with York and Luxaire. While smaller in market share than Carrier or Trane, Coleman positions its Echelon® series as a premium residential lineup that combines reliability, efficiency, and installer-friendly design.
For this review, I’m focusing on three flagship models: the CP9C Gas Furnace, the AC21 Air Conditioner, and the HC20 Heat Pump. Together, they demonstrate Coleman’s ability to deliver modern HVAC solutions with modulating, variable-capacity technology that rivals the bigger names. In my field experience, Coleman often appeals to homeowners who want premium comfort at competitive prices, especially in regions where local Johnson Controls dealers are strong.
